The violation of a law, the violation of a duty, are both definitions of the word “transgression“. In the book, Transgression: A Novel of Love and War, by James Nichol, those prime examples of defining the meaning of the word “transgression” are vividly brush stroked with Nichol’s word paintings.
Set during World War II and postwar, the historical aspect of the novel is fascinating, and the story line evokes mystery and intrigue as well. It is a story primarily of war and love, and the confines of such relationships within the framework of search and seizure in the Nazi stronghold in France. Transgression is a metaphor, in my opinion, for how war affects the emotional aspect of individuals, and what they will do or might do in to survive under harsh circumstances and extreme duress. Life under seige by the oppressor (and the oppressor is often ourselves), and how an individual’s coping mechanism is put into play is at the forefront of the novel.
The dangers of love affairs that cross the lines of political affiliation are explored in depth in this dramatic novel 1941, as Adele Georges tries to find her father who has been captured by the Nazis. While in the process of doing so, she meets a German soldier named Manfred who befriends her, tries to be helpful, and herein begins a romance that dooms her in the eyes of both sides fighting the war.
Their affair is hidden from Adele’s family who would not stop at anything to kill Manfred if they knew about the affair. And, by the same token, the Nazis would not stop at anything to kill him, if they found out about the affair. They are in a romantic bind. Eventuallly Manfred is deployed to Eastern Europe.
Adele is thought to be a collaborator for the other side, and the events depicted within this infrastructure in the book are explicit in detail, as they unfold before the reader’s eyes.
Within this framework there is a mystery lingering, the mystery of a disturbing find in a field. The year is 1946 and the gruesome discovery has been found by a child. This discovery begins a search for truth and identity in a postwar climate in Canada.
Through the detective work by the police chief (who is a character in himself), secrets are revealed that have followed Adele from one country to another.
If I sound vague, it is intentional, as I am trying not to reveal too much of the story line, because each detail is part of the whole.
Nichols’ writing is beautiful, yet gruesome at times, but each ugly act is pertinent to the story line, and not written for shock value. The historical aspect of Transgression is infused with much data.
From war and love to family and loss, the book is overwhelming, and the ending more so. Transgression is really a book that tells two stories in one, but is done so with such skill, as the two stories eventually fuse into one. James W. Nichol is masterful in his details and depictions of the horrors of war and the after effects that linger, as the past looms ever present in Adele’s life. It is a haunting read, filled with mystery and intrigue, and one that I highly recommend.
~~~~~~
© Copyright 2007 – All Rights Reserved – No permission is given or allowed to reuse my photography, book reviews, writings, or my poetry in any form/format without my express written consent/permission.
Sunday November 1, 2009 – 14th of Cheshvan, 5770





‘From war and love to family and loss…’
That is what it is all about, isn’t it? I read the book and still have a hard time getting over it. You’ll understand why eventually, I think.
HIGHLY recommended.
By: Deborah Rey on November 1, 2009
at 5:36 am
Deborah: It is a story that stays with you…
By: jewwishes on November 1, 2009
at 11:38 am
sounds good! your review definitely makes it sound intriguing…i’ve never heard of this book, i’ll have to check it out!
By: phyllis on November 1, 2009
at 7:38 am
Phyllis: I hadn’t heard of it either, but saw it in the book store and grabbed it.
By: jewwishes on November 1, 2009
at 11:37 am
I hate to point out anything lacking in Your blog but today in Poland is a day of remembering the dead and given the subject You chose for this blog I feel You missed to mention one important person that passed recently this year – Marek Edelman – the last commander of Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.
By: koala on November 1, 2009
at 4:37 pm
Koala, thanks for visiting and leaving your important message.
Today’s blog subject matter is strictly a book review, and nothing more.
May Marek Edelman’s memory be for a loving blessing.
By: jewwishes on November 1, 2009
at 6:08 pm
I have never heard of this book either.
By: ilanadavita on November 1, 2009
at 6:27 pm
Ilana…I hadn’t heard of it, either, and it was on a discount table in the book store.
By: jewwishes on November 1, 2009
at 6:59 pm
Sounds like a interesting read.
By: Bagels, Books and Schmooze on November 2, 2009
at 7:07 pm
Susan…it’s excellent.
By: jewwishes on November 3, 2009
at 2:36 pm
I’m definitely going to have to pick this one up! It sounds like it was written just for me!
By: Marie on November 3, 2009
at 7:20 am
Marie: It was written for you, and me too. LOL
By: jewwishes on November 3, 2009
at 2:33 pm
I think any story that touches the point of how war really effects us the normal human beings, the cannon fodder is important. Because wars are preserved in history books but their damage to every human being’s life that was in the way is not. After all wars destroy lives not only in the sense of death which in some aspects may be a relief in such environment. It pushes human beings to the core of our existence and the want to survive, by not losing ourselves, which is the hardest part to do. Obviously this is all an assumption anyway. How would I know?
By: carra on November 5, 2009
at 5:14 am
I completely agree with you.
The damage is endless, through the generations, even.
By: jewwishes on November 10, 2009
at 3:52 pm