Saving What Remains, by Livia Bitton-Jackson is a remarkable memoir and a compelling one. It relays a story that is gripping, and one infused with all of the aspects of intrigue, drama, suspense, and emotions. Logic does reign within the pages also, but the emotional story line grasped this reader immediately. Saving What Remains almost reads like a mystery novel, although it is a suspenseful and factual story.
Livia Bitton-Jackson and her family were deported to Auschwitz from their home in Samorin, Czechoslovakia. That she and her mother managed to survive is incredible in itself. Almost four decades later, Bitton-Jackson, returned to her childhood home town, then called Somorja, Hungary. Her husband accompanied her. She did this at great risk to herself, fearing she might be detained or arrested.
The reason for Bitton-Jackson’s return was due to the fact that the Jewish cemetery in Somorja was going to be flooded over by a new dam that was going to be built. Her mother had asked her to have the remains of her own parents (Bitton-Jackson’s grandparents) unearthed, disinterred and brought back to Israel for reburial there.
Herein begins the story of her quest, and all that went with it. The odds were against her, but she endeavored through every piece of red tape, fought the officials, ran in a frenzy to every town, city and every government office in order to obtain the permissions necessary to fulfill her requests for exhuming the bodies. She oversaw everything, as best she could under the duress and what seemed like insurmountable odds, in a country no longer recognizable to her own eyes and other senses.
Bitton-Jackson and her husband literally reached down into the graves and held the face of death in their hands. They physically touched their ancestors, felt the impressions of them that were left in the earth. Their feat was remarkable on so many levels, and is unbelievable and incomprehensible to the mind, although it was factual. I will leave you with these imprints, hoping to spur you on to read the memoir, yourself.
It is quite the thought-provoking memoir, leaving one to wonder what they would do. To what extremes would you go to bury your ancestors near you? Would any of us have the strength and courage to undertake what Bitton-Jackson did? This book is as much a tribute to her strength, fortitude and determination, as it is to her ancestors.
Saving What remains, by Bitton-Jackson is more than a memoir, more than a story of journeying back to one’s homeland. It is a story of a courageous sojourn to what once was, what no longer is. It is a story of memories that were in specific settings of time and place, and memories that no longer match the current scenes. Love and loss illuminate throughout the pages. Jewish life and death are ever present within the story line. The scent of homeland and culture are strong in this beautifully and vividly written account of Livia Bitton-Jackson’s journey. But, primarily, it is a story of the necessity for remembrance and honoring of our ancestors.
If we don’t remember, pay tribute and honor them, who will?!
I highly recommend Saving What Remains to everyone, and feel it belongs in every private and public library. It is an important historical memoir, reflecting on not only Jewish life and loss, ancestral remembrance, but social change and upheaval as well. It is a story, that once you begin, is difficult to put down. The odds were against success, and the story is incredible. It is one that is not readily let go of, after the reader finishes the last page.
Shabbat Shalom, everyone!
~~~~~~
© Copyright 2007 – All Rights Reserved – No permission is given or allowed to reuse my photography, book reviews, writings, or my poetry in any form/format without my express written consent/permission.
Friday August 7, 2009 – 17th of Av, 5769






That sounds like a must-have book. I was doing some reading the other day, linked to my family tree search, and was devastated to read about how many Jewish cemeteries in the UK have been lost to us. I have a terrible feeling that I will never find the graves of my ancestors that were lucky enough to live here rather than on the continent. Some ancestors devastated by the Shoah, others by municipal destruction. This does upset me terribly.
By: rachel on August 7, 2009
at 11:47 am
Rachel: It’s a wonderful book, so poignant, so compelling.
I know what you mean about the Jewish cemeteries in the UK. It is devastating, and I’m sure you are upset.
I had gone to Leeds where relatives are buried in three different cemeteries. They are not letting anyone in to one of the cemeteries, as the ground underneath is sinking, and the graves are sinking with them, along with the headstones. It isn’t violence that is doing damage, but the apparent erosion of the underground.
It was so sad to learn…and I had come from the U.S. to take photos, to daven, to pay respect, to leave stones, etc.
At least two of the cemeteries were in decent shape.
By: jewwishes on August 7, 2009
at 2:20 pm
What an incredible moving story, thanks jewwishes for the review.
Shabbat Shalom!
By: James on August 7, 2009
at 2:58 pm
Thank you, James.
Shabbat Shalom to you.
By: jewwishes on August 7, 2009
at 5:01 pm
Thank you so much for the book review. I knew the name of the author sounded familiar to me. I read a book over 10 years ago. Something in the title called 1000 years. Realized this is the same author. It was very good. If you have not read it, I recommend it to you. I want to pick up the book that you just reviewed.
Shabbat Shalom!
By: Susan on August 7, 2009
at 6:39 pm
Lori, can you email me there is something I want to talk to you about. I know sometimes we look out for each other about Jewish books that either of us would like to know about, and review. I am not sure about the book since I have not read it. I have only read the flap. If you would contact me at my blog. Just give me your email and I will then talk to you about it. http://bagelsbooksandschmooze.blogspot.com
Shabbat Shalom again.
Susan
By: Susan on August 7, 2009
at 6:51 pm
Thank you, Susan. I highly recommend this book.
Shabbat Shalom.
By: jewwishes on August 7, 2009
at 9:39 pm