Posted by: jewwishes | February 16, 2009

Jew Wishes On: Old Men at Midnight, by Chaim Potok

old-men-at-midnight-bychaimpotok Old Men at Midnight, by Chaim Potok is an exceptional book that encompasses three novellas. Each story stands on its own, and each one is compelling and intense.

The novellas are connected through Ilana Davita Dinn, who is the vehicle that bridges each story. Her patience and her attitude afford a sense of trust, and the primary characters feel they can confide in her. In a sense she is their muse, their confidant, the one person they feel they can tell their life story to.

Ilana believes that stories are a necessary facet of life, in which the past is important not only as historical information, but also as a mode of remembrance, for future generations.

I will give you a short glimpse into each story, but I won’t go into too much detail regarding the stories. If I do, I will end up give away much of the story lines.

The Ark Builder is the first story in Old Men at Midnight. It concerns a young Holocaust survivor, and his memories. Ilana is a young woman at the time, who encourages him to face his fears.

The second story is entitled The War Doctor, and involves a Jewish KGB officer who has defected to America. With her encouragement he is able to write about the events that involved a doctor who saved his arm. This story is quite disturbing in many aspects, as it deals directly with events of war, the horrors and the manipulations. It is extremely compelling. Ilana is a teaching assistant at Barnard University at the time, and the KGB officer is going to give a presentation there.

The Trope Teacher is the last story in the novella trilogy, and Ilana is a bit older and has become a writer. Her neighbor is a man who is a professor on warfare, its conflicts and events, and who is grappling with his wife’s illness. Once again, she is the encouraging force in his writing his memoir.

Potok’s Old Men at Midnight is a compelling and poignant trilogy of stories, and each one delves into issues of the Holocaust, and how the events have fashioned the lives of the characters, emotionally, and how the after-effects affect the individual lives. Each story is brilliantly written, and Chaim Potok’s masterful writing illuminates the pages. The book is filled with vivid imagery, and written with excellence. I highly recommend Old Men at Midnight to everyone.

I personally own and have read this book.
~~~~~~
Jew Wishes…Peace to you all.
© Copyright 2007 – All Rights Reserved – No permission is given or allowed to reuse my photography, book reviews, writings, or my poetry in any form/format without my express written consent/permission.

Monday February 16, 2009 – 22nd of Sh’vat, 5769


Responses

  1. I just checked; our library has this one. I’ll add to my list of books to check out.

    • Leora: I’m glad your library has this one!

  2. I read these stories years ago – Chaim Potok is one of my favorite writers. I am in Holland right now and I took some of Potok’s from my shelves there to take back home with me to Armenia. It is high time for a reread of some of his books. I am already looking forward to it!

    By the way, did you know that the same Ilana Davita is also the main character in Potok’s Davita’s Harp? In that novel she is still a child, though.

    • Myrthe: Yes, I know that she is the same Ilana-Davita. I plan to read Davita’s Harp again, it’s been years (decades) since I have.

      I’m sure you will enjoy the books you are bringing back to Armenia!

      It’s good to hear from you!

  3. Chaim Potok has been one of my favourite writers for many, many years. I am not Jewish but a practising Christian who, like Pope John Paul II, considers the Jewish people our elder brothers and sisters in faith. Without the Root of Jesse, there is no Jesus Christ, there is no Christian faith.

    His work is elemental and deeply moving. He probes our souls and exposes, with great precision and compassion, the darkness and light there.

    I have just finished Old Men at Midnight and, as usual, am left with visual and psychic images which won’t go away.

    I was once tempted to write him, back in the ’80s, to tell him how deeply touched I was by his writing. I had just finished Davita’s Harp. Something he wrote in that novel — We [Jews] are either loved too much or hated too much — stopped me from writing him a fan letter.

    • Chaim Potok is one of my favorite authors, also, Jane. Thanks for the visit.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories