Posted by: jewwishes | February 15, 2009

The Rabbi’s Daughter, by Reva Mann

the-rabbis-daughter The Rabbi’s Daughter, by Reva Mann is a book I found difficult to read due to its unappealing content (my opinion).

It is theoretically a book of discovery, redemption and search for spirituality within a framework of what the author sees as oppression and lack of self-esteem. Mann’s life is defined in many facets, from her explicit sexual encounters, and sexual addiction, to her using of drugs, to her marital failings.

Mann is the daughter of a highly respected Rabbi, and the granddaughter of the head of the Rabbinic Counsel of Israel. Her childhood was an unhappy one, and she felt that she had to tow the religious mark, or suffer the consequences from her father, and suffer them from who she perceives as an uncaring mother. She did not agree with her father’s ethics, religious responsibilities, or, from her/Mann’s perspective, her mother’s self-absorbed way of being.

It is fine to disagree with your parents, but Mann doesn’t seem to acknowledge that her father did what he knew best, from how he was brought up by his own parents (which doesn’t make him right, yet doesn’t make him wrong). He continued the cycle of his own history, and then came along Mann who wasn’t willing to conform or adhere to her family’s religious foundation and life style.

Her journey to find self-acceptance, identity and to find a spiritual foundation has her crossing many boundaries. She writes vividly about these events and escapades, and that is what turned me off, and led me to want to finish the book as quickly as possible, in order to be done with it. I skimmed over much of the sexual material, because I had no need to read about her involvements in a graphic manner. Some individuals don’t mind the types of details that are within the pages of The Rabbi’s Daughter, but I didn’t enjoy reading them.

Some of the events in the book seemed as if they were exaggerated, or superficial, but that is just my opinion, and not necessarily a reflection of the fact that they were actually over-extended.

On the whole it is a memoir written with clarity and detailed word images. Mann’s The Rabbi’s Daughter is possibly a good book to read for those that are having difficulty with self-esteem, and identifying their spirituality, and what is best for them in that respect. Judaism has many outlets for Torah study, and religious satisfaction, and in the end, Reva Mann seemingly found her niche, spiritually. It is also a book that those who are involved in addiction, whether it be sexual, drug, alcohol, or otherwise, might be able to garner some reflection from, as they could possibly relate to the experiences of the author.

I could not relate to any portion of the book, in any aspect. I also did not feel empathy or sympathy for the author.

~~~~~~
Jew Wishes…Peace to you all.
© Copyright 2007 – All Rights Reserved – No permission is given or allowed to reuse my photography, book reviews, writings, or my poetry in any form/format without my express written consent/permission.

Sunday February 15, 2009 – 21st of Sh’vat, 5769


Responses

  1. I’ve seen this book, on many ocassions, and have been unable to pick it up for the reasons you mention. I’m glad SOMEONE read it and told me how it was, though :)

    • Chavi: Thanks for the input. :)

  2. I have also seen this book around for the past year.
    I did not pick the book up because of the content and thought she would be bad mouthing Judaism.
    I am not a prude but anyone who looks for escape and using sex and drugs need some counseling. I hope she does find her way back and to her family.

    • Susan: I’m glad to be done with the book.

  3. Sometimes we are our own worst enemy. I think we do things to spite our parents when we are young but in actuality we are hurting ourselves worse than we are hurting them.
    I wanted to thank you for the kind comments you have left me friend. They have soothed my heart.
    Please stop by I am having a give-a-way.
    Love Nita <3

    • Yes, we are often more harmful to ourselves than we think.

      Thinking of you sweet lady.

  4. thanks for the review, which is, as always, wonderfully done. it is in my bedside pile and has been for a long time for all the reasons you and other mention. it was, however, in the stack to take on my upcoming trip to israel and has now moved off the stack thanks to your review. i have four books, i think that will be enough:-) (we’re only gone a week but those are some long plane rides!)

    • Phyllis: Thanks for stopping by. Yes, it is a long plane ride, but I think you could do with other books to read, like you said.

      Have a safe journey.

  5. I read it a few months ago and did not like it at all. I agree with every one you have written.
    I often had the feeling things were written to shock more than anything else.

  6. Ilana Davita: I think she might have been trying to use use shock value, also.

  7. Thanks for your review. I have this in the temple library and I appreciate your input.

    • Thanks, Marie.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories